【The Journal of Aesthetic Education】MATTEO RAVASIO:Appearance Emotionalism in Music: Analysis and Criticism

来源:The Journal of Aesthetic Education,Vol. 53, No. 3 (Fall 2019), pp. 93-105   作者:   时间:2019-09-26

Abstract

This paper is composed of two related parts. The first raises questions regarding the characterization of the phenomenology of music listening required by Davies's theory of musical expressiveness, appearance emotionalism. I will identify two possible readings of the theory, a thick and a thin one, and claim that the former represents the basic characterization of what it is to hear expressive music according to appearance emotionalism. The thick characterization is to be preferred, I will claim, both on the grounds of textual evidence and of overall consistency and explanatory power. The second part of the paper discusses a criticism of appearance emotionalism I advanced in a recently published paper, along with its consequences for aesthetic education. In the remainder of the paper, I address Davies's twofold reply to my objection. I contend that both replies fail to address at least some of the problems I raised. The first reply fails because of Davies's own view of emotions, while the seconds fails if one accepts the thick characterization of appearance emotionalism I offer in the first half of the paper.



  Read the full text:Appearance Emotionalism in Music: Analysis and Criticism

版权所有 © 真人棋牌游戏大厅 地址:北京市海淀区颐和园路5号北京大学红六楼 邮编: 100871 电话: 010-62751905